Kitten?

Olivia with Little Kitty

Olivia loves all animals and most especially our 2 cats. One is fat and despite her official name of Martha, we just call her Big Kitty. She is 8 years old and we got her when we moved into this house from Grandma McNiven's never ending supply of Farm cats. She is mine and a bit snobby and can be cross but is overall great with the kids. She runs from Olivia. Partly because Olivia screams at her to get her to run.

3 years later Carter wanted a kitty. Off we went to Grandma's to pick one out. (It should be noted that I only like Orange kitties and at the time both the mom and dad of the farm cats were both orange). This kitty was called Tiger and has since been referred to as Little Kitty because she is, well, little. Carter built forts and played with her for hours and as a result will tolerate ANYTHING! We thought she was deaf because even the vacuum didn't bother her. Olivia can carry her around.

So a girl I know has a litter of cats that will be ready around Olivia's birthday (Nov 13) and has 2 orange kittens in the bunch. Carter was 6 when we got Little Kitty and Olivia will only be 3. Yet I know she would love a kitty. I get my cats fixed the minute they are old enough and they spend ample time out doors killing and bringing me presents. 90% of the time they are outside. But I have kept them as kitten inside for the first winter. So that is my debate and the reason for my poll. please participate and help me decide what to do!!